Post Chronology

March 2017
« Jan    

InFullBloom Archives


Speaking Engagements

Predict and Prepare sponsored by Workday 12/16

The Bill Kutik Radio Show® #171, 2/15
The Bill Kutik Radio Show® #160, 8/14
The Bill Kutik Radio Show® #145, 1/14
Workday Predict and Prepare Webinar, 12/10/2013
The Bill Kutik Radio Show® #134, 8/13
CXOTalk: Naomi Bloom, Nenshad Bardoliwalla, and Michael Krigsman, 3/15/2013
Drive Thru HR, 12/17/12
The Bill Kutik Radio Show® #110, 8/12
Webinar Sponsored by Workday: "Follow the Yellow Brick Road to Business Value," 5/3/12 Audio/Whitepaper
Webinar Sponsored by Workday: "Predict and Prepare," 12/7/11
HR Happy Hour - Episode 118 - 'Work and the Future of Work', 9/23/11
The Bill Kutik Radio Show® #87, 9/11
Keynote, Connections Ultimate Partner Forum, 3/9-12/11
"Convergence in Bloom" Webcast and accompanying white paper, sponsored by ADP, 9/21/10
The Bill Kutik Radio Show® #63, 9/10
Keynote for Workforce Management's first ever virtual HR technology conference, 6/8/10
Knowledge Infusion Webinar, 6/3/10
Webinar Sponsored by Workday: "Predict and Prepare," 12/8/09
Webinar Sponsored by Workday: "Preparing to Lead the Recovery," 11/19/09 Audio/Powerpoint
"Enterprise unplugged: Riffing on failure and performance," a Michael Krigsman podcast 11/9/09
The Bill Kutik Radio Show® #39, 10/09
Workday SOR Webinar, 8/25/09
The Bill Kutik Radio Show® #15, 10/08

Keynote, HR Tech Europe, Amsterdam, 10/25-26/12
Master Panel, HR Technology, Chicago, 10/9/012
Keynote, Workforce Magazine HR Tech Week, 6/6/12
Webcast Sponsored by Workday: "Building a Solid Business Case for HR Technology Change," 5/31/12
Keynote, Saba Global Summit, Miami, 3/19-22/12
Workday Rising, Las Vegas, 10/24-27/11
HR Technology, Las Vegas 10/3-5/11
HR Florida, Orlando 8/29-31/11
Boussias Communications HR Effectiveness Forum, Athens, Greece 6/16-17/11
HR Demo Show, Las Vegas 5/24-26/11
Workday Rising, 10/11/10
HRO Summit, 10/22/09
HR Technology, Keynote and Panel, 10/2/09

Adventures of Bloom & Wallace

a work in progress

Dennis Howlett-Inspired Post #1 — Multi-tenancy In HRM SaaS

Dennis Howlett

This is the first of what I suspect will be many posts for which the impetus is a question from a specific colleague, in this case Dennis Howlett.  So as to give credit, or at least curiosity, where it’s due, this one’s for you.  

Having seen me refer to (Dennis might say pimping) my latest post on Twitter, “Multi-tenancy: Tables Stakes For HRM In 2011,” and no doubt after reading every post and article I’ve written on the subject (all of which are posted on this blog site), he sent me a perfectly reasonable and very Dennis-like direct tweet:  “Why do you keep banging on about MT?  It doesn’t make sense unless there is something humungous I am missing.”  

Well, if you’ve read any of Dennis’ work on ZDNet, AccMan or followed him on Twitter , you’d know that he’s a pretty smart guy with strong opinions.  So, if after reading my complete works on the subject of multi-tenancy, I had somehow not made the business case to Dennis, shame on me.  I immediately responded to his inquiry and, given his feedback, my response was useful.  But the more I thought about it, I more I felt that, if my previous writings hadn’t made the business case for multi-tenancy to Dennis’ satisfaction, I had better take my latest response to his question and turn it into a post — and so I have. 

This is what she wrote: 

“There’s something humongous that you’re missing, at least as regards the HRM domain.  First, there’s a ton of dynamic business rules/content/etc., including regulatory stuff as well as common/good practice stuff (e.g. competency models) that modern software abstracts to meta data and which needs to be shared across customers (so one instance of this meta data shared across tenants and inherited by each, with the appropriate geographies for regulatory stuff).  The advantages in cost, reduction of errors, speed of updates, etc. from being able to do this type of inheritance is substantial and, hopefully, factors into what vendors charge or could charge their customers.  Second, there are good opportunities for aggregating useful data across customers (i.e. across tenants), ranging from the type of crowdsourcing that helps vendors see what features are being used, where there are challenges using them, etc., all of which should help vendors invest their resources more wisely and fix issues before they are huge, to benchmarking (e.g. ADP’s labor market data) to creating pools of contractors or applicants shared across tenants (obviously with the permission of all involved parties).  While both inheritance and aggregation across customers can be done in single tenant virtualized environments with a variety of add-ons, all those add-ons introduce complexity, cost, and points of failure.  These are by no means the only reasons I feel so strongly about multi-tenancy, but it’s been a long day of meetings and travel — really three long days — and, to use your expression (which I love), I’m knackered.  Happy to do a call on all of this if we can schedule for next week.” 

There are so many reasons for multi-tenancy in a SaaS world that we should now be asking the question: why would you want to subscribe software from an HRM software vendor or run on a BPO platform that isn’t multi-tenant?  There are a few reasonable answers to this question, but they don’t apply to the vast majority of us.  But if you too have questioned my perspective on this, I hope that the above (plus the other materials on this blog site) has made the case.

10 comments to Dennis Howlett-Inspired Post #1 — Multi-tenancy In HRM SaaS

  • […] payroll solution which Naomi Bloom does a very good job in outlining the benefits in this article but it is obvious that the complexity and length of time it would take as well as competitive […]

  • […] payroll solution which Naomi Bloom does a very good job in outlining the benefits in this article but it is obvious that the complexity and length of time it would take as well as competitive […]

  • […] payroll solution which Naomi Bloom does a very good job in outlining the benefits in this article but it is obvious that the complexity and length of time it would take as well as competitive […]

  • Naomi,
    Thanks for speaking on behalf of us, the producer and staunch supporter of multi-tenancy in SaaS model. It sounded like you took our thoughts and bloomed them in beautiful words. The multi-tenancy concept is not new if you have worked in Mainframe based shared environment of last century.
    One big advantage that is underestimated by many is the technical support aspect; i can’t tell how easy it has become for our tech support people to address issues in SaaS environment and ten times easier for the clients to manage their environment. It’s a win-win for everyone. Of course there are fear mongerers out there who keep on creating security scare about everything but those false fears are created mostly for selfish reasons like promotinng their product or services.

    • Naomi Bloom

      Thank you so much for sharing your perspective here. You might also enjoy reading a related post: Multi-tenancy is table stakes in 2011.

  • Bill Kutik

    “…creating pools of contractors or applicants shared across tenants (obviously with the permission of all involved parties)” refers, of course, to Taleo and its Talent Exchange.

    Though other vendors are beginning to realize the value of what they have in this regard.

    • Naomi Bloom

      Bill, You’re of course right about Taleo, but there’s more happening/about to happen in this area. The possibilities are substantial, and there’s reason to believe that applicants, learners, contingent workers, and external org designees (as in your leaving your 401K $$ to Harvard, therefore designating Harvard as the external org which is to receive something of value under your employer’s total compensation plans) will be willing to be pooled in ways that offer them distinctive benefits. I might also add that LinkedIn already represents a pooling of “applicants” that we share almost without thinking about it.

  • Naomi,

    Great post on points supporting the case for SaaS multi-tenancy. Your are most certainly on point.


  • […] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Naomi Bloom and Naomi Bloom, jonholden. jonholden said: RT @InFullBloomUS: Naomi's new blog post: Dennis Howlett-Inspired Post #1 — Multi-tenancy In HRM SaaS #IN […]

Leave a Reply

You can use these HTML tags

<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>